• News
  • Lake Facts
  • About

Lake Scientist

Supreme Court rejects second lock closure request

2
  • by Dave Hochanadel
  • — March 24, 2010

Supreme-Court The Supreme Court has again refused Michigan’s request for a preliminary injunction to close two Chicago locks in an effort to stop the Asian carp, Reuters reports.

The High Court had denied the first request in a January 19 decision. But Michigan Attorney general Mike Cox, along with numerous environmental groups, had hoped the introduction of new DNA evidence of the Asian carp entering Lake Michigan would be enough to change the justices’ decision.

Michigan also changed its second request to accommodate concerns from state of Illinois and Chicago sewer authorities who worried lock closure could cause massive flooding and other problems. The language of the second request said the locks would be temporarily closed but could be opened to protect public health as safety, such as alleviating flood-level water or allowing vessels to pass for emergency response.

Many environmental groups along with the $7 billion Great Lakes fishing industry support the lock closure as a means to protect Great Lakes waters and ecosystems from the invasive species.

Solicitor General Elena Kagan urged the Supreme Court against the injunction, however, warning of the effects it could have on the Chicago-region and national economies. The court denied this second motion in a one-sentence order.

Although this is a setback for Michigan’s legal fight to stop the Asian carp, it’s far from over. Michigan still has a pending case before the High Court to reopen the 90-year-old “Chicago Diversion” case, which decided how Illinois manages the waterways that connect the Mississippi River Basin and the Great Lakes. The Supreme Court has scheduled a review of this request for April 16. Pennsylvania, New York, Ohio, Wisconsin, Minnesota, Indiana and the province of Ontario all support this reopening.

Michigan loses new request in Great Lakes carp case [Reuters] Image Credit: http://www.flickr.com/photos/tom_ruaat/ / CC BY-SA 2.0

Share

You may also like...

  • Asian carp might have second route to Great Lakes
  • Great Lakes art exhibit open in Buffalo
  • Rocks along the shore of Lake Superior near Copper Harbor, Michigan. Research Brief: Lake-Wide Microplastic Abundances in Lake Superior
  • No new Great Lakes invasives since 2006

2 Comments

  1. Legal efforts against Asian carp continue | Lake Scientist says:
    July 21, 2010 at 10:48 AM

    […] states are continuing the legal battle against the Asian carp. After the Supreme Court twice rejected requests for a preliminary injunction to close two Chicago locks, the Great Lakes states are […]

    Reply
  2. Federal judge will hear Asian carp case | Lake Scientist says:
    August 24, 2010 at 9:55 AM

    […] September hearings will be the first time the case will be heard on its merits. The Supreme Court twice rejected requests for a preliminary injunction to hear the case but did not rule on the legal claims […]

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Time limit is exhausted. Please reload CAPTCHA.

FishSens SondeCAM HD
  • Recent Posts

    • Detroit River, Amherstburg, OntarioResearch Brief: Implications of Updated Phosphorous Loads from Lake Huron and the Detroit RiverNovember 24, 2023
    • Lake Victoria from the shore of Jinja, UgandaResearch Brief: Research Need in the Lake Victoria BasinNovember 17, 2023
    • 2012 Western Lake Erie Basin MeetingResearch Brief: 20-Year Phytoplankton Biomass Trends in Lake ErieNovember 10, 2023
    • Protecting Chicago’s Lakefront: Freshwater Beach MonitoringNovember 6, 2023
    • Satellite view of the African Great Lakes region.Research Brief: Recognizing the Need for Harmonized Monitoring Efforts in the African Great LakesNovember 3, 2023
  • Popular Tags

    Great Lakes research research summary pollution Lake Erie invasive species Product Spotlight Algae research brief runoff international Lake Michigan nutrient-loading Ohio dissolved oxygen climate change EPA temperature eutrophication toxic waters USGS ice phosphorus lake science Asian Carp

©2023 Fondriest Environmental Inc. | Questions? Call 888.426.2151 or email customercare@fondriest.com